Manuscript No.

Reviewer:

Date Sent:

Overview Please rate each item as Good, Fair, or Poor.

1. Importance and interest of topic to ultiBASE readers. Good Fair Poor

2. Quality of literature review and consistency with the relevant literature. Good Fair Poor

3. Clarity of the goals of the research or development effort. Good Fair Poor

4. Adequacy of the research method and accuracy of data analysis. Good Fair Poor

5. Presentation and interpretation of findings, inferences and conclusions. Good Fair Poor

6. Inclusion of appropriate implications for practice and/or policy. Good Fair Poor

7. Grammatical construction; writing style; clarity of ideas; use of non-sexist language. Good Fair Poor

Comments:

The following section will be forwarded to the author

a. Paper Critique
Please provide a constructive critique on the paper to provide author feedback and to guide our selection process.

b. Summary - Key areas for improvement

c. Recommendation Accept Accept with minor revisions Resubmit after major revision Reject